2024 BMW X1 vs. 2025 BMW X5 Review

Picture of the 2024 BMW X1

2024 BMW
X1

MSRP*: $40,500 to $49,900
See details & photos

Find Your Best Price Today!

Picture of the 2025 BMW X5

2025 BMW
X5

MSRP*: $65,700 to $90,000
See details & photos

Find Your Best Price Today!

MPG - City 23 - 25 MPG 17 - 23 MPG
MPG - Hwy 31 - 34 MPG 22 - 27 MPG
Seating Capacity 5 seats 5 seats
Cargo Space 46.9 - 57.2 ft3 72.3 ft3
Engine
  • 241-hp, 2.0-liter, 4 Cylinder Engine (Gasoline Fuel)
  • 312-hp, 2.0-liter, 4 Cylinder Engine (Gasoline Fuel)
  • 375-hp, 3.0-liter, Straight 6 Cylinder Engine (Gasoline/Mild Electric Hybrid)
  • 523-hp, 4.4-liter, 8 Cylinder Engine (Gasoline/Mild Electric Hybrid)
Transmission Automatic Automatic
Drivetrain All Wheel Drive All Wheel Drive, Rear Wheel Drive
Horsepower 241 - 312 hp 375 - 523 hp
Towing Capacity Info not available 6,603 lbs
Exterior Length 177.2 - 177.4 in 194.3 in
Exterior Width 72.6 in 78.9 in
Leg Room Front 40.4 in
Rear 37.0 in
Front 39.8 in
Rear 37.4 in
Head Room Front 42.1 in
Rear 39.3 in
Front 40.7 - 40.8 in
Rear 38.7 in

*MSRP and Invoice prices displayed are for educational purposes only, do not reflect the actual selling price of a particular vehicle, and do not include applicable gas taxes or destination charges.

Comparison Review

Comfort
The BMW X1 offers rear passengers about the same room to stretch out as the BMW X5, with comparable head- and legroom. The BMW X1 will be popular with taller drivers and passengers in the front seat, due to its greater front head- and legroom than the BMW X5.

Convenience
With the BMW X5, you will definitely be making fewer stops at the gas station than with the BMW X1, due to its tank size and fuel economy.

Cost
There are a lot of factors to consider when calculating the overall cost of a vehicle. The main consideration is Manufacturer's Suggested Retail Price (MSRP). Clearly, the BMW X1 is a better financial choice over the BMW X5, when considering MSRP.

Dimensions
Since the BMW X1 is much slimmer than the BMW X5, it'll be much easier to find a wide enough space in a crowded parking lot. If you go with the BMW X1, you'll have a much easier time finding a large enough space to park than you will with the BMW X5.

Handling
The BMW X1 has a smaller turning radius than the BMW X5, allowing you to more easily maneuver in and out of tight spots.

Performance
When it comes to horsepower, the BMW X1 has a lot less horsepower than the BMW X5.

Powertrain
Due to its much higher torque, the BMW X1 does a much better job of transmitting its engine's horsepower to its wheels than the BMW X5.

Utility
In terms of seating, you'll be able to fit about the same number of people in both the BMW X1 and the BMW X5. The BMW X1 has significantly less cargo capacity than the BMW X5.